← Back to BillCut Daily

Existing Home Sales Just Did Something That Hasn't Happened Since 2009

Persona #5 ยท Vol: 0

Existing home sales fell again last month, and the drop wasn't a small one.

According to the National Association of Realtors, sales of previously owned homes slid to a pace not seen in roughly 15 years.

For anyone trying to buy or sell right now, the number confirms what open houses and Zillow refreshes have been screaming for months: this market is stuck.

The headline number matters less than the reason behind it.

Sellers who locked in a 3% mortgage during the pandemic look at today's rates near 7% and quietly decide to stay put, which keeps inventory painfully thin.

Buyers who could afford a home two years ago now stare at the same listing with a payment hundreds of dollars higher.

That standoff has a name economists love: the lock-in effect.

Roughly 80% of current homeowners with mortgages hold rates below 6%, and a huge share sit under 4%.

Trading a 3.5% loan for a 6.8% one can add $800 or more to a monthly payment on a typical loan.

So what does it mean for your wallet if you're not buying or selling this year?

When existing homes don't sell, people don't hire movers, buy appliances, or remodel kitchens.

That ripples into local economies and can soften demand for everything from furniture to contractors.

It also keeps rent demand high, because would-be buyers who give up keep signing leases.

Fewer competing listings means a well-priced home can still draw multiple offers in desirable areas.

Homes that sit for 60 days get stale, and stale listings get lowball offers.

Real estate agents report that buyers are far pickier than they were in 2021, and inspection requests are back with a vengeance.

For buyers, the takeaway is less bleak than the headlines suggest.

Less competition means you're not automatically losing to a cash offer $50,000 over asking.

Some sellers are finally covering closing costs or buying down rates.

Builders, meanwhile, are offering incentives that existing sellers can't match, which is one reason new construction has been stealing market share.

If they drift toward 6%, a wave of locked-in sellers could finally list, easing inventory and loosening the logjam.

If they climb back toward 7.5%, expect more of the same: few listings, slow sales, and a market that moves only when life forces someone's hand, like a job change, a divorce, or a growing family.

Our take: this isn't a crash, and it isn't a recovery.

It's a staring contest, and the people feeling it most are first-time buyers who never had a cheap mortgage to give up in the first place.

Final Thoughts

Until rates move meaningfully lower or incomes catch up, expect more months of headlines that sound dramatic but describe the same standoff.

Continue Reading