← Back to BillCut Daily

New Home Sales Are Booming While Existing Homes Sit Unsold

Persona #4 ยท Vol: 0

New home sales jumped 20.5% in January to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 1.04 million, according to the Commerce Department, the fastest pace since early 2022.

That's a striking number in a housing market most buyers describe as frozen.

The catch: it's almost entirely a story about new construction, not the resale market most Americans actually shop in.

Sales of newly built homes are climbing because builders can do something existing homeowners won't: cut prices and buy down mortgage rates.

Roughly 60% of builders surveyed by the National Association of Home Builders are offering incentives, and many are paying points to push a buyer's rate from around 7% down toward 5.5% or lower for the first year or two.

A seller with a 3% mortgage and no urgency has little reason to compete with that.

The median price of a new home sold in January was $446,300, up about 5% from a year earlier, but that figure hides the deal-making.

Builders are also shrinking square footage and building more townhomes and entry-level plans, which keeps the sticker price from spiking the way it did in 2021.

In many metros, a brand-new home now costs less per square foot than a comparable 20-year-old resale.

If you're shopping, the math is worth running carefully.

A permanent rate buydown is worth far more than a one-year teaser, because you'll still be paying the loan long after the incentive expires.

Ask the builder's lender for a Loan Estimate and compare it against at least two outside lenders; builder-affiliated lenders are sometimes competitive and sometimes not, and the sales office won't volunteer the difference.

Watch the fine print on closing cost credits too.

Many are tied to using the builder's preferred lender, and some vanish if you switch.

Get any credit in writing before you sign, and confirm whether it's applied at closing or rolled into the loan.

Existing home sales, by contrast, remain near a 30-year low.

Inventory is slowly improving, but much of what's listed is either priced optimistically or needs work.

That mismatch is exactly why builders are winning: they're selling certainty, warranties, and a payment a buyer can actually qualify for.

One risk worth naming: incentives are profit margin, and builders can only give away so much.

If rates fall meaningfully, those buydowns will shrink fast and the current deals will look better in hindsight.

If rates stay high, builders keep subsidizing.

Our take: the headlines about a hot housing market are misleading, but the opportunity is real if you're willing to buy new.

Final Thoughts

Treat every incentive as a negotiating chip, not a favor, and run the numbers on the total cost of the loan rather than the monthly payment in year one.

Continue Reading