← Back to BillCut Daily

Used Car Prices Are Finally Falling, But Not Where You'd Expect

Persona #1 · Vol: 0

After two years of sticker shock, used car shoppers are catching a break.

Wholesale auction prices dropped for the third straight month, and that relief is starting to reach dealership lots.

But the discounts aren't landing evenly, and where you live may matter more than what you drive.

The Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index, which tracks wholesale prices, slipped again in the latest reading, down roughly 6% from its peak.

Retail prices typically follow wholesale with a 60- to 90-day lag, which means the cars sitting on lots right now were bought cheaper than the ones sold last spring.

Dealers who overpaid for inventory are the ones stuck absorbing the difference.

The catch is what's actually getting cheaper.

Late-model trucks, SUVs, and luxury vehicles are seeing the steepest cuts because dealers loaded up on them when demand was hot.

Compact sedans and hybrids, meanwhile, are holding value stubbornly.

Blame gas prices and a buyer pool that suddenly cares about miles per gallon again.

A three-year-old Camry might cost you nearly what it did a year ago, while a comparable Silverado has shed thousands.

There's a second wrinkle: the used market is splitting by price tier.

Fewer trade-ins and a weak new-car market from 2020 to 2022 mean the typical off-lease supply never showed up.

That shortage pushed buyers toward older, higher-mileage vehicles, which keeps cheap inventory expensive.

If your budget is tight, you're competing in the toughest corner of the market.

The average used car loan rate sits above 11% for many buyers, and the typical monthly payment has crept past $500.

Even with a lower sticker price, a higher rate can wipe out the savings.

A $2,000 price drop on a five-year loan at current rates saves far less than shoppers expect once interest is factored in.

Run the full payment, not just the asking price.

Metro areas with strong public transit and high EV adoption are seeing softer used prices, while rural markets with long commutes hold firmer.

Regional auctions in the Midwest and South are clearing inventory faster than coastal lots.

That means the same truck can carry a four-figure price gap depending on the zip code.

Shop late in the month and late in the quarter, when dealers chase sales targets.

Get preapproved before you walk in, because a competing offer is the only real leverage you have.

And don't sleep on certified pre-owned programs, which are seeing more aggressive pricing as manufacturers push to move metal.

The takeaway is simple: the used car market is cooling, but it's cooling unevenly.

Patience and homework still beat timing the market.

Our take: the worst of the used car squeeze is behind us, but relief will feel modest for anyone shopping under $20,000.

Final Thoughts

If you can wait a quarter and widen your search radius, you'll likely do better than the person who buys this weekend.

Continue Reading