You hand an insurance company a lump sum, and it promises you income later.
What the brochures rarely put in bold is how many layers of fees sit between your money and that paycheck.
A salesperson pushing an indexed or variable annuity can pocket anywhere from 4% to 8% of what you invest, paid upfront by the insurer and quietly baked into your contract.
On a $100,000 rollover, that's thousands gone before your money even starts working.
Variable annuities often carry mortality and expense fees around 1.25% a year, plus fund management fees, plus a rider charge if you want a guaranteed income stream.
Stack them and you can easily cross 2% to 3% annually, every single year you hold the contract.
A 2.5% annual drag on a $200,000 account costs roughly $5,000 a year, and it compounds against you.
Over a 20-year retirement, the difference between a 6% return and a 3.5% return is often six figures, money that never shows up on a statement line you'd notice.
Surrender charges punish you for changing your mind.
Most contracts lock in a 7% fee if you bail in year one, sliding down to zero over five to ten years.
Got a better offer, a health crisis, or a sudden need for cash?
You may pay thousands just to reach your own money.
Indexed annuities dress this up with caps and participation rates instead of a flat fee.
You might be told you'll capture "up to" the market's upside, but a 6% cap plus a 0.95% rider fee means a strong 20% market year still lands you a modest gain, while the insurer keeps the rest.
First, ask for the full fee disclosure in writing and add up every percentage point, including the commission.
Second, compare the total cost against a plain low-cost index fund, a fee-only financial planner, or a simple Treasury ladder.
Third, never buy an annuity inside an IRA.
You're already getting tax deferral, so you're paying for a benefit you didn't need.
A straightforward single-premium immediate annuity can function like a personal pension, and some buyers genuinely want that guaranteed check.
The problem is the complex, fee-heavy products sold with a smile and a steak dinner.
Our take: if a product's costs can't be explained in two minutes on one page, that's your answer.
Ask what the seller earns, get the numbers in writing, and run them past someone who isn't paid to sell you the contract.
Final Thoughts
Your future self is the one paying for the fine print.