The pitch sounds simple enough: hand over a lump sum, and the insurance company sends you a check every month for life.
But the gap between what an annuity promises and what it actually pays often comes down to a maze of fees buried in the fine print.
Those charges have a name, and most buyers never add them up.
According to industry research, the total cost of owning certain annuities can run from roughly 1% to more than 3% of your account value every year.
On a $200,000 balance, a 2.5% annual drag works out to about $5,000 vanishing before you see a dime of growth.
Over a 20-year retirement, that compounds into a six-figure hit, which is real money for households already stretched by grocery bills and rent.
There's a mortality and expense charge for the insurance protection itself, an administrative fee, and often a fund management fee on top if your money sits in subaccounts.
That guaranteed income benefit you were sold?
It usually carries its own annual charge, sometimes 1% or more.
So does the death benefit, and so does any long-term care feature tacked onto the policy.
If you change your mind and pull money out early, typically within the first five to seven years, the insurer can take a slice that starts near 7% and steps down each year.
Many contracts also impose a market value adjustment that can shrink your payout further when rates move.
Variable annuities add another wrinkle, since their fees tend to run higher than fixed or indexed versions.
The trade-off is potential market growth, but after a bad year you can lose value and still owe the same charges.
Start by demanding the fee table, not the brochure.
Every contract has one, and it lists each charge in plain numbers you can compare side by side.
Ask for the total annual cost as a single percentage, then ask what that looks like in dollars on your specific deposit.
If an agent can't or won't put it in writing, that's your answer.
Consider whether you actually need the guaranteed income rider or whether a plain fixed annuity, a bond ladder, or a low-cost index fund inside an IRA gets you closer to the same goal.
Guarantees cost money, and sometimes you're paying for protection you'll never use.
Also check the free-look period in your state, which usually gives you 10 to 30 days to cancel for a full refund.
That window is your last clean exit before surrender charges kick in, so use it to read the contract with fresh eyes.
None of this means annuities are automatically a bad deal.
For some retirees, a lifetime paycheck is worth the price, especially if it keeps them from outliving their savings.
The problem is buying one without knowing what it costs.
Our take: the fee disclosure should be the first page of the pitch, not a footnote you find three weeks later.
Ask for the numbers in dollars, compare at least two quotes, and walk away from anyone who dodges the math.
Final Thoughts
Your retirement is too expensive to fund someone else's commission twice.