← Back to BillCut Daily

Existing Home Sales Just Did Something That Hasn't Happened in Years

Persona #3 ยท Vol: 0

The National Association of Realtors reported that existing home sales jumped 3.4% in March to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of roughly 4.02 million.

That's the strongest reading since December 2022, and it marks the first time in over a year that sales have climbed above the 4 million mark.

On paper, that sounds like the housing market is finally thawing.

But before you pop champagne or panic about missing your window, take a closer look at what's actually driving the number.

The surge isn't really about buyers suddenly feeling flush.

March's sales reflect contracts signed in January and February, when mortgage rates briefly dipped into the low 6% range.

That dip pulled a chunk of fence-sitters off the sidelines.

Once rates crept back toward 7%, the momentum cooled almost immediately.

In other words, this wasn't a structural shift.

And the people celebrating loudest tend to be the ones with something to sell you.

Who benefits from a "hot" housing headline?

Real estate brokerages, mortgage lenders, and the NAR itself, which uses these numbers to lobby for policies that keep transactions flowing.

Their incentives are not the same as yours.

A single monthly uptick is not a trend, no matter how many breathless headlines call it a "comeback." The inventory picture is the real story, and it's still ugly.

Total housing inventory sat at around 1.11 million units heading into spring, which is roughly a 3.1-month supply at the current sales pace.

A balanced market is closer to six months.

What inventory exists is skewed toward higher price points, because that's where sellers can afford to move.

Meanwhile, homeowners who locked in 3% mortgages during the pandemic have little reason to trade a cheap loan for a 7% one.

That "lock-in effect" keeps affordable starter homes scarce and keeps prices stubbornly high.

For buyers, the practical takeaway is unglamorous: a good rate week matters more than a good headline.

If you're shopping, watch weekly mortgage rate data, not monthly sales reports that describe deals signed two months ago.

Get pre-approved before rates move, and be ready to act fast when they dip.

This spring's activity is being fueled by buyers who are rate-sensitive and inventory-starved.

Overpricing in that environment is a great way to sit on the market while your neighbor's reasonably priced listing goes under contract.

And for anyone waiting for a crash to swoop in and buy cheap?

Sales are rising because of temporary rate relief, not because prices are collapsing.

Distressed inventory remains historically low.

What the March number actually tells us is that there's enormous pent-up demand sitting just beneath the surface.

Every time rates dip even slightly, buyers pounce.

Our take: treat this sales bump as a weather report, not a climate change.

One strong month built on a fleeting rate dip doesn't fix a housing market that's short millions of homes and still punishing anyone without an existing low-rate mortgage.

Final Thoughts

If you're making the biggest purchase of your life, base your decision on your budget and your timeline, not on a statistic designed to make agents feel optimistic.

Continue Reading