← Back to BillCut Daily

Existing Home Sales Just Did Something That Hasn't Happened in Years

Persona #3 ยท Vol: 0

The National Association of Realtors reported that existing home sales rose in its latest monthly reading, and the headlines quickly declared the housing market is "back." Before you break out the champagne, look at what's actually driving the number: a small slice of buyers who can afford today's rates, competing for a stubbornly thin supply of homes.

Existing home sales measure closings, not signed contracts, so the figure reflects deals that were struck in late summer and early fall.

A single month's uptick can say more about what happened two months ago than what's happening at open houses this weekend.

The bigger story is inventory, and it's still historically tight.

Many homeowners locked in mortgages at 3% or 4% during the pandemic and have little incentive to sell and trade that payment for something near 7%.

That "lock-in effect" keeps would-be sellers on the sidelines, which keeps prices elevated even as affordability crumbles for first-time buyers.

Real estate agents, mortgage lenders, and homebuilders all have an interest in convincing you the ice is thawing.

Builders in particular have leaned on rate buydowns and smaller floor plans to move inventory, which is a quiet admission that sticker prices alone aren't working.

If you're shopping right now, the practical takeaways matter more than the headline.

Get pre-approved before you tour anything, because sellers in competitive pockets still expect it.

Ask your lender to quote you a rate with and without points, then calculate how many years of staying put it takes to break even on those upfront costs.

Don't assume a falling median price in your metro means you'll get a deal.

The median moves with the mix of homes sold, so a jump in starter-home closings can drag it down even when individual asking prices hold firm.

Look at price-per-square-foot for comparable homes on your street instead.

Renters watching this should also pay attention.

When sales stall, some would-be sellers become reluctant landlords and list their homes for rent, which can add supply to certain rental markets and soften asking rents slightly.

It's not a guarantee, but it's worth checking whether your lease renewal offer reflects local conditions.

For anyone waiting for a dramatic crash before buying, the data so far doesn't support that script.

Tight supply acts like a floor under prices in most markets, even with rates where they are.

It's grinding, and that's a frustrating place to be if you need a roof.

Our take: a one-month sales bump is a data point, not a turning point, and the people most excited about it usually have a commission riding on your decision.

Watch inventory and local days-on-market figures for three or four months before you let a headline change your plans.

Final Thoughts

If the numbers keep climbing while supply loosens, that's a trend worth believing.

Continue Reading