← Back to BillCut Daily

Existing Home Sales Just Did Something That Hasn't Happened Since 2010

Persona #5 · Vol: 0

Existing home sales fell 4.9% in March to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 4.02 million, according to the National Association of Realtors.

That's the weakest pace since November 2010, when the housing market was still clawing its way out of the foreclosure crisis.

For anyone trying to buy or sell a house right now, the number is less a statistic than a status report on a stalled market.

The headline dip is partly a timing quirk—sales are counted when a deal closes, not when it's signed, so a stretch of brutal winter weather delayed closings that might have landed in March.

It's the same math that has defined housing for nearly three years: mortgage rates hovering around 6.5% to 7%, home prices that refuse to meaningfully drop, and a pool of would-be sellers sitting on loans with rates half that.

Roughly 70% of outstanding mortgages carry rates below 5%, and a large share sit under 4%.

Moving means trading a 3% loan for a 7% one, which on a $400,000 mortgage adds more than $1,000 to the monthly payment before you even account for a higher purchase price.

Buyers who can afford today's rates compete for a shrinking pile of listings, and everyone else waits.

First-time buyers accounted for just 32% of sales, below the roughly 40% that's typical in a healthy market.

They're being squeezed from both ends: rents that have climbed for years, and credit card APRs near record highs making it harder to save a down payment while carrying balances.

Meanwhile, sellers who do list are often discounting—the median existing-home price slipped slightly year over year, a rare soft patch after a long run of gains.

For buyers, the practical takeaway isn't to wait for a crash that economists keep not delivering.

It's to get specific about your breakeven window.

Buying at 7% only pays off long-term if you plan to stay put long enough to refinance later or pay the loan down, and if you can absorb the payment without leaning on credit cards.

That last part matters, because a mortgage you can technically qualify for and a mortgage you can actually afford are two different numbers.

For sellers, the old playbook of listing high and waiting for multiple offers is mostly dead outside a few tight markets.

Price realistically, expect inspection requests, and understand that buyers today are running the same math you are—and they've already seen the payment.

A house that sits for 60 days in this market usually isn't a marketing problem.

It's frozen, and freezes are their own kind of painful.

The people hurt most aren't the ones with 3% mortgages—they're the renters and first-time buyers footing the bill for a standoff they had no part in creating.

Final Thoughts

Until rates come down or incomes catch up, expect more months like this one.

Continue Reading