← Back to BillCut Daily

New Home Sales Are Sliding, and Buyers Just Got More Leverage

Persona #4 ยท Vol: 0

New home sales fell to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of about 623,000 in September, down roughly 11 percent from a year earlier, according to U.S.

It's the kind of headline that sounds like bad news for everyone.

For anyone actually shopping for a house right now, it's closer to an opening bid.

Builders spent most of the last three years holding the line on price because resale inventory was historically thin.

Completed homes sitting unsold โ€” what the industry calls spec inventory โ€” have climbed to levels not seen since the tail end of the last housing downturn.

A builder paying interest on finished, empty houses is a builder motivated to negotiate.

The most visible giveback is the mortgage rate buydown.

Instead of cutting the sticker price, many builders are paying points to knock a buyer's rate down by a full percentage point or more for the first few years.

On a $400,000 loan, shaving a point off a 7 percent rate saves roughly $260 a month early on.

Then there are the quiet discounts: free upgraded appliances, closing cost credits of $10,000 or more, finished basements thrown in, and lot premiums waived.

None of it shows up in the headline price, which is exactly why builders prefer it.

It lets them protect the "comps" for future phases while still moving inventory.

The discounting is heaviest in Sun Belt markets like Austin, Phoenix, and parts of Florida, where builders overshot demand during the pandemic boom.

In tight Northeast and Midwest metros, you'll still get a shrug and a waitlist.

If you're flexible on location, the spread between those two worlds is enormous right now.

If you're shopping, ask three specific questions.

What's the total incentive package in dollars, not percentages?

Is the rate buydown permanent or does it reset after year two?

And how long has this specific home been finished and unsold?

That last one tells you how much room you have.

Get pre-approved with two lenders before you tour a model home, including one your builder isn't affiliated with.

Builder-preferred lenders often bundle incentives, but you can't judge the deal without a competing quote in hand.

Also budget for the HOA dues, which run higher in new communities and never stop.

One more thing worth knowing: new construction contracts often include arbitration clauses and escalation language.

Read the fine print or pay a real estate attorney a few hundred dollars to do it.

That fee is cheap insurance on the largest purchase most people ever make.

The sales slowdown isn't a crisis for buyers โ€” it's a shift in who has leverage at the table.

Builders need to move standing inventory, and their incentives are doing the work that a price cut would normally do.

Final Thoughts

Ask for more than what's advertised, and be ready to walk if the numbers don't land.

Continue Reading