← Back to BillCut Daily

Points or No Points? The Mortgage Math Banks Hope You Skip

Persona #3 ยท Vol: 0

Walk into any mortgage closing and you'll hear the same pitch: pay a little extra upfront, and we'll shave your rate.

It usually isn't, and the gap between the two options can quietly cost you thousands.

Mortgage points, sometimes called discount points, are a fee you pay the lender at closing to buy a lower interest rate.

On a $350,000 mortgage, that's $3,500 for a single point, and it might knock your rate down by roughly a quarter of a percentage point.

The trade-off is simple on paper: more cash today, smaller payments later.

The catch is the break-even point, and it's longer than most buyers assume.

If that $3,500 saves you around $55 a month, you need about 64 months, more than five years, just to get your money back.

Sell, refinance, or move before then, and you've handed the lender a gift.

This is where the sales script gets fuzzy.

Loan officers are paid on volume and often on the rate they lock, so a bigger upfront fee isn't automatically the better deal for you.

There's also a sneaky detail buried in the paperwork.

Points paid on a home purchase are usually tax-deductible in the year you pay them, while points on a refinance typically have to be deducted over the life of the loan.

That difference changes the math, and plenty of borrowers never hear it explained.

People who plan to stay put for the long haul, have cash sitting idle, and want the lowest possible payment.

Someone who expects to move in three years, or who needs that cash for an emergency fund, or who could instead pay down high-interest credit card debt, is usually better off taking the no-points rate.

Asking for a lender credit in exchange for a slightly higher rate flips the whole equation, and some lenders will budge if you shop around.

If rates fall in the next couple of years, and many forecasters expect some cooling, you'll likely refinance anyway.

Paying thousands for points today to lock in a rate you'll replace in 2027 is a losing bet.

Run your own break-even number before you sign anything, and ask the lender to show it in writing.

The uncomfortable truth is that points are less a smart financial strategy and more a product designed to look like one.

The lender gets your cash immediately, and you carry all the risk of moving, refinancing, or rates dropping.

Final Thoughts

Do the arithmetic yourself, or pay a fee-only advisor to do it, because the person across the table is not on your side of the ledger.

Continue Reading