← Back to BillCut Daily

Points or No Points: The Mortgage Math Most Buyers Get Wrong

Persona #5 · Vol: 0

Mortgage rates are still hovering near two-decade highs, and lenders are pitching a familiar trade-off: pay more upfront to shave your rate, or keep cash in your pocket and accept a higher monthly bill.

It rarely is, because the break-even math depends on how long you actually stay in the home.

One point typically costs 1% of the loan amount and lowers your rate by roughly 0.25 percentage points, though the exact discount varies by lender and market.

On a $400,000 loan, one point runs $4,000.

Say you're choosing between a 7% rate with no points and a 6.75% rate after paying one point.

The monthly difference on a 30-year loan is about $67.

Divide your $4,000 cost by that savings and you break even in roughly 60 months — five years.

Sell or refinance before then, and you've handed the lender money for nothing.

That timeline is the whole ballgame, and it's longer than most buyers assume.

Closing costs already eat into equity, and a refinance resets the clock entirely.

If there's any chance you'll move within a few years — a job transfer, a growing family, a market shift — the no-points route usually wins.

There's also a cash-flow question people skip.

Every dollar spent on points is a dollar not available for an emergency fund, a higher down payment, or paying down other debt.

Credit card balances charging 20%-plus interest will cost you far more than a quarter-point rate discount will save.

Points can make sense in specific cases: you're confident you'll stay put for at least seven to ten years, you have cash beyond your reserves, and you've compared offers from several lenders.

Sellers sometimes cover points as a concession, which changes the math in your favor — free money toward a lower rate is worth taking if the loan terms are otherwise competitive.

Run the break-even calculation yourself before signing anything.

Ask the lender for a Loan Estimate showing the rate with and without points, then divide the point cost by the monthly savings.

If the answer is more years than you plan to stay, keep your cash.

One more trap: "no-cost" mortgages aren't free.

The lender recovers the cost through a higher rate or rolled-in fees.

Compare the total interest paid over your expected time in the home, not just the headline rate. **Our take:** Points are a bet that you'll stay put long enough to win, and most Americans move or refinance sooner than they expect.

Final Thoughts

Unless a seller is footing the bill, keeping your cash and taking the higher rate is often the safer play in a volatile market.

Continue Reading