← Back to BillCut Daily

Short-Term Health Plans Are Cheap for a Reason

Persona #5 · Vol: 0

The pitch lands in your inbox right after a job change or a layoff: coverage starting tomorrow, premiums under $200 a month, no open enrollment window required.

For millions of Americans staring down a gap between paychecks and a plan, short-term health insurance looks like the obvious fix.

Consumer advocates and state regulators say the sticker price hides the part that matters most — what happens when you actually get sick.

Short-term plans were originally built as a stopgap of less than a year.

Federal rules expanded them in 2018 to last up to 364 days and be renewed for up to three years in many states.

Insurers are not required to cover the ten essential health benefits that Affordable Care Act plans must include.

That list covers prescription drugs, maternity care, mental health treatment, and substance abuse services.

Pre-existing conditions can be excluded entirely, and a plan can deny you outright for a past diagnosis.

A short-term policy might pay a flat dollar amount per day in the hospital rather than the actual bill, or cap total payouts at a few hundred thousand dollars.

One emergency surgery, a cancer diagnosis, or a premature birth can blow past those limits and leave you with the balance.

Because the plans are not ACA-compliant, they also do not count toward the requirement to have minimum essential coverage, and you cannot get subsidies to lower the premium.

If you are healthy, between jobs for a few months, and mainly want protection against a catastrophic accident, a short-term plan can beat paying the full unsubsidized price of a marketplace plan.

The mistake is treating it like real insurance and skipping the fine print.

Read the exclusions page before the benefits page.

Check whether prescriptions are covered at all, whether there is a separate deductible for drugs, and what the annual or lifetime maximum payout is.

Your better options are often closer than you think.

Losing job-based coverage opens a special enrollment period, usually 60 days, to buy a marketplace plan — frequently with subsidies that make it cheaper than the short-term quote.

Losing Medicaid or aging off a parent's plan also triggers one.

COBRA keeps your old plan but shifts the full premium to you, which is expensive yet sometimes worth it.

If you are under 26, a parent's plan may still cover you.

The cheapest premium is not the same as the cheapest outcome.

Ask one question before you buy: if I get hit by a car next month, what is the most I will pay out of pocket?

Our take: short-term plans are a tool, not a safety net, and they are marketed to people at their most financially vulnerable.

If you are healthy and truly in a short gap, they can bridge you.

Final Thoughts

If anyone in your household has an ongoing condition, a prescription, or a pregnancy on the horizon, put the money toward a marketplace plan instead.

Continue Reading