← Back to BillCut Daily

Short Term Health Insurance Is Cheap for a Reason

Persona #5 ยท Vol: 0

Short term health insurance is having a moment.

With Obamacare premiums climbing and open enrollment locked to a few weeks a year, these stripped-down plans have become the go-to pitch for anyone who missed the deadline or just can't stomach another monthly bill.

The appeal is obvious: some policies cost less than a single week of groceries.

Short term plans aren't required to cover the ten essential health benefits that ACA plans must include.

That means no guaranteed coverage for prescription drugs, maternity care, mental health treatment, or preventive checkups.

You're buying a discount card, not comprehensive coverage.

Insurers can reject you for pre-existing conditions, and they can charge women more than men for the same policy.

If you've had a bout with high blood pressure, asthma, or even a past back injury, you may be denied outright or handed a policy that excludes anything related to your history.

A 2019 study in the Journal of the American Medical Association found that short term plans paid out just 50% of billed medical costs, compared with 80% for ACA-compliant plans.

Translation: you pay more of the bill when something actually goes wrong.

One appendectomy or a broken leg from a pick-up basketball game could wipe out a year of premium savings.

There's a federal rule that used to limit these plans to three months, with no renewal guarantees.

The Trump administration extended the maximum term to 364 days and allowed renewals up to 36 months.

The Biden administration later proposed rolling that back, though the rules have bounced around in court and agency guidance ever since.

The practical upshot: if you buy one of these, read the fine print on how long it actually lasts, because a "year-long" plan can end abruptly.

People between jobs who need a bridge for a few months, healthy twenty-somethings with no dependents, or early retirees waiting for Medicare to kick in.

If you have a chronic condition, take regular prescriptions, or might start a family soon, these policies can leave you exposed at the exact moment you need help.

If you're shopping on the individual market, start at HealthCare.gov first.

You might qualify for subsidies that make a real ACA plan cheaper than the sticker price suggests.

If you still go the short term route, check the deductible, the out-of-pocket maximum, the drug formulary, and whether your doctors are even in the network.

A low premium means nothing if the plan won't pay when you need it. **The bottom line:** Short term health insurance can be a useful stopgap for the young and healthy, but treating it like real coverage is a gamble most families can't afford to lose.

Final Thoughts

If the premium looks too good to be true, it usually is.

Continue Reading