← Back to BillCut Daily

Social Security's 2025 Raise Is Already Shrinking

Persona #3 ยท Vol: 0

Every October, roughly 70 million Americans wait for one number: the Social Security cost-of-living adjustment.

This year it landed at 2.5 percent, and by the time the checks actually arrive in January, plenty of retirees will wonder where it went.

Here's the math that gets buried under the headline.

The COLA is calculated using a subset of inflation called the CPI-W, which tracks urban wage earners and clerical workers.

Retirees spend a bigger share of their budgets on health care and housing, two categories that have outrun the general inflation rate for years.

Translation: the adjustment is based on a basket that doesn't match the one retirees actually shop from.

The result is a raise that technically exists but functionally lags.

Then comes the part nobody puts in the press release.

Medicare Part B premiums are typically deducted straight from Social Security checks, and those premiums tend to rise faster than the COLA itself.

A 2.5 percent bump on a $1,900 monthly benefit is about $48.

If your Part B premium jumps by $10 or more, a meaningful slice of that raise never touches your bank account.

Advocates have pushed for years to switch to the CPI-E, an experimental index weighted toward elderly spending.

It would likely produce slightly larger adjustments most years.

It has also gone nowhere in Congress, partly because it would add to program costs at a moment when the trust fund's depletion date is a live political fight.

The formula keeps the official increase modest, which keeps the long-term funding gap from looking quite as terrifying on paper.

That's a real budget consideration, but it's also a quiet transfer of risk onto people on fixed incomes.

The practical takeaway is uncomfortable but useful: don't budget around the percentage.

Pull your last three bank statements and compare what you spent on groceries, utilities, and prescriptions against what you spent a year earlier.

That gap, not the COLA, is your real inflation rate.

If you're still working and approaching retirement, this is your reminder that Social Security was designed as a floor, not a plan.

Every year the formula lags, the floor gets a little thinner relative to the cost of standing on it.

Our take: the annual COLA announcement has become a ritual that generates headlines and false comfort in equal measure.

The number is real, but it's calculated on a formula that was never built to reflect how older Americans actually spend.

Final Thoughts

Until that changes, treat the raise as a small cushion, not a solution.

Continue Reading