← Back to BillCut Daily

Used Car Prices Are Finally Falling, but Not Where You'd Expect

Persona #1 · Vol: 0

After nearly three years of sticker shock, the used car market is cooling off—just not evenly.

Manheim's latest Used Vehicle Value Index, which tracks wholesale auction prices, has slipped for several consecutive months.

That decline is starting to trickle down to dealership lots, though shoppers in some segments are still staring down near-pandemic pricing.

Late-model trucks and SUVs—the vehicles that drove the craze—are seeing the steepest cuts, with some 1- to 3-year-old models down 8% to 12% from their 2022 peaks.

Meanwhile, budget-friendly sedans and hatchbacks under $15,000 remain stubbornly scarce and pricey.

Dealers say the sub-$10,000 car has nearly vanished, partly because fewer were built during the chip-shortage years and partly because owners are holding onto them longer.

First, new car inventory has recovered, and automakers are back to dangling 0% financing and rebates—pulling buyers away from used lots.

Second, repossession volumes are climbing as pandemic-era loan deferrals expire, pushing more supply into auctions.

Third, higher interest rates have shrunk the pool of shoppers who can afford a $600 monthly payment on a used car.

That last point matters more than the sticker price.

The average used car loan rate now sits above 11% for many buyers, and over 14% for subprime borrowers, according to Edmunds data.

On a $25,000 loan over 60 months, that's roughly $120 more per month than the same loan at 2021's rates.

A cheaper car with an expensive loan can still wreck your budget.

If you're shopping, target the 3- to 5-year-old sweet spot—depreciation has already hit hard, but the vehicle still has life left.

Get pre-approved at a credit union before you walk into a dealership; their rates often beat dealer financing by a wide margin.

And never negotiate on monthly payment alone—dealers can stretch loan terms to 84 months to hide a bad price.

If you're selling or trading, timing is less forgiving than it was.

Carvana and CarMax offers have come down from their 2021 highs, and private-party sales now require realistic pricing.

Check completed listings on sites like Facebook Marketplace and Autotrader rather than asking prices—the gap between the two has widened sharply.

The bigger picture: this is a normalizing market, not a crashing one.

Analysts don't expect a return to 2019 prices because the total supply of used vehicles is still below pre-pandemic levels, and the average car on the road is now over 12 years old.

That structural shortage puts a floor under prices.

For households juggling grocery bills, rent, and credit card debt, the relief is real but modest.

A $2,000 price cut helps, but a two-point rate hike can erase it.

The smartest move is to separate the two decisions—pick the car, then fight hardest on the financing.

The used car correction is welcome news, but it's a slow thaw rather than a sudden spring.

Shoppers who wait for a full return to 2019 pricing may be waiting a long time, while those who focus on financing terms today can capture real savings right now.

Final Thoughts

In this market, the loan matters as much as the lot.

Continue Reading