← Back to BillCut Daily

FHA Loans Still Let You Buy With 3.5% Down. The Catch Is Sneakier

Persona #3 · Vol: 0

FHA loans keep getting pitched as the first-time buyer's cheat code: low down payment, forgiving credit standards, seller-paid closing costs.

What the brochures skip is how much you'll pay for the privilege, and how a single unpaid medical bill can quietly kill the whole thing.

That 3.5% down requires a credit score of 580 or higher.

Between 500 and 579, you need 10% down — and good luck finding a seller who picks your offer over a conventional buyer with 20% down in a competitive market.

Then there's mortgage insurance, which is where FHA loans earn their reputation as the expensive option.

You pay an upfront premium of 1.75% of the loan amount, rolled into what you borrow.

On top of that, annual premiums run roughly 0.55% to 0.85% depending on your loan size and down payment.

Here's the part that stings: if you put down less than 10%, that annual premium typically lasts the entire life of the loan.

Conventional loans let you drop PMI once you've built enough equity.

The debt-to-income limit is another hidden hurdle.

Most lenders want your total monthly debts — car payment, student loans, credit cards, the new mortgage — under 43% of your gross income, though some will stretch to 50% with compensating factors.

Lenders will count student loans at 1% of the balance even if you're on an income-driven repayment plan paying $0.

Self-employment income gets scrutinized hard.

Two years of tax returns, and lenders average them.

If you wrote off a lot of expenses to lower your tax bill, congratulations — you also lowered the income they'll count.

Freelancers and gig workers get caught here constantly.

Now the part that catches people off guard: collections.

FHA doesn't automatically disqualify you for medical collections or old charge-offs, but lenders layer their own rules on top.

A single $2,000 collection that's been sitting there since 2019 can trigger a requirement to pay it off or set up a payment plan — which then raises your DTI and can push you over the limit.

Borrowers routinely discover this three weeks before closing.

The home has to meet FHA minimum standards — no peeling paint, working heat, functioning roof, no obvious safety hazards.

That rules out a lot of fixer-uppers, which is ironic since FHA loans are marketed to buyers with limited cash.

If the appraisal flags repairs, the seller has to fix them or you walk.

Lenders and the mortgage insurance fund, mostly.

FHA loans aren't a scam — millions of families have used them successfully, and for borrowers with bruised credit or thin savings, they're sometimes the only door that opens.

But they're also a product that keeps costing you long after closing.

The practical move: get quotes for both FHA and conventional loans side by side, including the full life-of-loan insurance cost.

If your credit score is anywhere near 620 or above, conventional pricing may beat FHA even with a slightly higher rate.

Final Thoughts

Run the actual numbers before assuming the "easy" loan is the cheap one.

Continue Reading