← Back to BillCut Daily

Used Car Prices Are Falling, But Not the Way You Think

Persona #2 ยท Vol: 0

If you have been holding off on buying a used car because everything still looks expensive, there is some good news buried in the data.

Wholesale prices at dealer-only auctions have been dropping for months, and that slowdown is finally starting to show up on the lots.

The catch is that it is showing up unevenly, and where you live and what you drive matters more than the headline number.

According to tracking from Manheim and other auction analysts, wholesale used vehicle values have cooled noticeably from their pandemic peaks.

Dealers buy at those auctions, so when wholesale prices fall, retail prices usually follow within a few weeks.

But dealers are not in a hurry to slash stickers while shoppers keep paying.

That gap between what a dealer paid and what you are quoted is where your negotiating room lives right now.

Late-model trucks and SUVs are still holding value better than small sedans and EVs, partly because of shifting demand and federal tax credit rules on electric models.

Meanwhile, certain three- to five-year-old compacts and hybrids are sitting on lots longer, which means dealers are more willing to talk.

If your budget is tight, the smart move is to target the segments nobody is fighting over.

Financing is the other half of the equation, and it can wipe out any savings from a lower sticker price.

Average used car loan rates have hovered in the high single digits for many borrowers, and they climb fast if your credit score is shaky.

Before you fall in love with a car, get preapproved through a credit union or your bank.

Walking in with a rate in hand turns the finance office from an ambush into a comparison.

Do not skip the inspection, even on a certified pre-owned car.

A $150 to $200 mechanic's inspection is the cheapest insurance you will buy this year.

Ask for the vehicle history report, check for flood damage if the car came from a storm-hit region, and confirm the title is clean.

A great price on a car with a branded title is not a deal, it is a future headache.

If you are selling instead of buying, the same cooling market works against you.

Your trade-in offer may come in lower than the online instant quotes you saw last year.

Get at least three quotes, including one from a CarMax-style instant buyer and one from a local dealer, and be ready to walk away from the first number.

The bottom line: this is a better market than 2022, but it rewards patience and homework over luck.

Pick a segment with soft demand, line up financing before you shop, and treat the inspection as non-negotiable.

Final Thoughts

The deals are out there, they are just not advertised.

Continue Reading