← Back to BillCut Daily

Used Car Prices Are Finally Falling, But the Best Deals Come With a

Persona #4 · Vol: 0

After two brutal years, the used car market is showing real signs of cooling.

Wholesale auction prices have dropped for months, and that relief is starting to reach dealership lots.

If you've been holding off on buying, this could be the moment you've been waiting for — with one important caveat.

According to Manheim's used vehicle value index, wholesale prices have slipped well below their pandemic peak.

Retail lots typically follow wholesale trends by six to eight weeks, which means the discounts shoppers see today were baked in weeks ago.

Dealers who overpaid for inventory last spring are now motivated to move metal before values slide further.

On popular three-year-old models — think compact SUVs and sedans from Toyota, Honda, and Hyundai — you can now find listings thousands below what they commanded a year ago.

Certified pre-owned programs are also slashing finance rates to lure buyers who got spooked by high borrowing costs.

Here's the catch: not every segment is falling equally.

Trucks and large SUVs are holding value stubbornly, and anything with low mileage in a desirable trim still sells fast.

The steepest discounts are landing on EVs, where a wave of lease returns has flooded the market.

That's great news if you want a used electric car, but resale values on those models may keep dropping, so plan to keep it a while.

Where you buy matters as much as what you buy.

Independent lots and online sellers like Carvana and CarMax are racing to clear inventory, and some are offering delivery credits or waived fees.

Meanwhile, new-car dealers are pushing certified pre-owned deals with warranty coverage that independent lots can't match.

Financing is the hidden variable most shoppers overlook.

The average used car loan rate still sits near 14% for buyers with subprime credit, but shoppers with good scores are seeing offers in the 6% to 8% range — down from last year.

Get preapproved at a credit union before you walk onto a lot.

Walking in with a rate in hand turns the finance office from an ambush into a negotiation.

A few practical moves can save you real money right now.

Shop the last week of the month, when sales quotas pressure managers to deal.

Have a mechanic inspect any used car before you sign, even certified ones.

And don't skip the vehicle history report — flood-damaged cars from recent storms are quietly circulating through auctions and showing up on unsuspecting lots.

If you're trading in, timing gets trickier.

Your current car is also worth less than it was a year ago, so the falling market cuts both ways.

The gap between your trade value and the car you want may have narrowed, which is what actually matters — not the headline price of either vehicle.

The takeaway: this is a buyer's market again, but only for shoppers who do their homework.

Prices are softer, rates are better, and dealers are hungrier than they've been since 2021.

The folks who win are the ones who get preapproved, compare certified and independent options, and refuse to fall in love with the first car they drive.

Our take: don't wait for prices to bottom out, because nobody rings a bell at the bottom.

If you need a car and you've got financing lined up, the current mix of lower prices and easing rates is about as good as it's been in years.

Final Thoughts

Just budget for the unexpected repair — even a "deal" on a used car can come with a surprise.

Continue Reading