← Back to BillCut Daily

Housing Inventory Is Rising, but the Cheap Stuff Isn't Coming Back

Persona #3 · Vol: 0

After nearly three years of bidding wars and "sold above asking" panic, the housing market is finally loosening up.

Active listings in many metros are up double digits from a year ago, and sellers are cutting prices at the highest rate since 2019.

If you've been waiting on the sidelines, it feels like the tide is turning.

But before you pop the champagne, take a closer look at what's actually sitting on the market.

A lot of the new inventory is not starter homes.

Builders spent the last two years finishing luxury subdivisions and higher-priced townhomes, while the entry-level segment stayed starved.

In many markets, the median listing price is still climbing even as the number of listings grows.

More choices, yes — more affordable choices, not so much.

Meanwhile, the "lock-in effect" is finally cracking, but slowly.

Homeowners who snagged 3 percent mortgages have been refusing to sell because moving means trading that rate for something near 7 percent.

As life events (divorce, retirement, job moves) force more of them to list anyway, supply creeps up.

It's also a trickle, not a flood, and it doesn't fix the underlying shortage that got us here.

Real estate portals, agents, and lenders all want you to believe the market is normalizing so you'll transact.

A headline about "inventory surging" drives clicks and foot traffic, even when the specific homes in your ZIP code are still scarce and still expensive.

Renters hoping to buy face a math problem: mortgage rates near 7 percent plus higher insurance and taxes can make a monthly payment bigger than the rent they're trying to escape.

First-time buyers are also competing against investors who pay cash and skip inspections.

More inventory doesn't automatically mean more leverage for you.

Watch your specific submarket, not national headlines.

Track days-on-market and price cuts in the neighborhoods you actually want.

Get pre-approved so you can move fast if a real deal appears.

And negotiate — inspection contingencies and seller credits are back on the table in a way they weren't two years ago.

The honest take: inventory is improving at the margins, and that's worth something.

But anyone promising a return to 2019 prices is selling a story, not a market.

Final Thoughts

The shortage took a decade to build, and it won't unwind in a season.

Continue Reading