← Back to BillCut Daily

Used Car Prices Are Finally Falling, but There's a Catch

Persona #2 · Vol: 0

If you've been putting off buying a used car because the prices felt like a bad joke, there's some good news rolling in.

After years of sticker shock, used vehicle prices have been cooling off.

According to data tracked by Manheim, wholesale used-car prices have dropped steadily from their pandemic-era peaks.

That means the deals you see on lots and in private listings are getting a little less painful.

But before you sprint to the nearest dealership, here's the catch: the drop isn't happening evenly.

Trucks and SUVs are still holding their value better than small sedans, and anything under $15,000 is still tough to find.

The cheapest cars tend to be older, higher-mileage models that get snapped up fast.

So the "average" price drop you read about might not show up on the specific car you want.

There's another wrinkle — interest rates.

Even if the price tag is lower, financing a used car still costs more than it did a few years ago.

The average rate on a used-car loan has hovered around 9% or higher for many buyers, and that adds up fast.

A $20,000 loan at 9% versus 5% can cost you well over a thousand extra dollars across the life of the loan.

So the monthly payment might not feel like a bargain even when the sticker is smaller.

New car inventory has recovered, so more people are buying new and trading in their old rides.

Repossessions have also ticked up as households feel the squeeze from inflation and higher credit card bills.

And rental companies are selling off fleet vehicles again, which adds even more metal to the market.

Still, don't expect 2019 prices to come roaring back.

Experts say we're normalizing, not crashing.

Depreciation is returning to something closer to historic norms, but the overall cost of owning a car — insurance, repairs, maintenance — has climbed too.

Insurance premiums have jumped double digits in many states, which can wipe out the savings from a lower purchase price.

If you're in the market, a few moves can help.

Get pre-approved for financing through a credit union before you walk onto a lot, so you're not stuck with the dealer's markup.

Shop the last two weeks of the month and the end of a quarter, when salespeople are chasing bonuses.

And always pay for a third-party inspection — a cheap car with hidden problems is no bargain.

Prices vary a lot by region, and a two-hour drive can sometimes save you a couple thousand dollars.

Sites that track listing prices can show you whether a car has been sitting on the lot for weeks, which gives you room to negotiate.

The bottom line is that the used-car market is finally tilting back toward buyers, but it's not a fire sale.

Patience and homework still matter more than timing.

My take: this is the first real break car shoppers have gotten in years, so if you can wait a few more months and save a bigger down payment, you'll be in a stronger spot.

Final Thoughts

Just don't let a lower sticker price trick you into ignoring the loan terms — the financing is where the real money hides.

Continue Reading